patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Moms Talk: Do You Agree With a Shorter Feb. Vacation?

Bernards Township next year will join other county schools, including Somerset Hills, in having only one week off after New Year's.

 

Editor's Note: It's difficult to write this column without noting the sudden passing of William Zimmermann, who soon would have turned 20, in a March 7 car accident while on spring break in Mexico. For the many residents with children who may know members of Billy's family in Bernards Township schools, the tragedy seems just a little bit closer to home.

For those of us who moved into Bernards Township part-way through our children's school careers, the extra weeklong February vacation may have been a bit of a mixed blessing.

Sure, the kids loved having that extra week's holiday in February, and then yet another week off in April.

But the school year always ended pretty late in Bernards Township — it's June 26 for this year. It would have been the equally late end date set in 2013-14 before next year's calendar was revised at the beginning of March by the Board of Education.

So, now the new last day of school for next year is June 20, 2014. The trade-off is that February vacation has been shortened to Feb. 17-18 for next year, and the Martin Luther King holiday again has been eliminated.

That last day of school IS more reasonable, especially for older students who may be heading off to summer activities, or even attending college orientations.

Still, that February vacation — "ski week" as some have called it — has always been pretty popular in Bernards Township.

And some parents and students weren't too anxious to give it up.

At the March 5 school board meeting, parent Laura Begg, while thanking the staff for the undertaking to review the district calendar, noted that students had supported keeping the full February break in the survey. "As students get older, they need to visit colleges," she said.

In a survey issued earlier this year to parents, staff and Ridge High School juniors and seniors, 65.8 percent of those upperclass students who responded said they would like to see school end seven to 10 days earlier. However, at the same time 45 percent said they would like to keep the full two weeks off in 2014, while taking away some individual holidays, Schools Superintendent Nick Markarian reported.

In the survey, an overwhelming majority of parents said they wanted to see the school year end earlier than had been scheduled.

Begg, who said she was speaking on behalf of several parents, told the school board that February break is valuable "family time" for many students. She said the April break would be scheduled during a time when spring sports are underway, making it difficult for parents and students to get away together.

Although that reason may not have seemed as compelling on March 4, does it hit home with a little more sharpness this week, after seeing how short our time with our children may be? Did other parents (as did this one) see the photos of William Zimmerman on family trips, which were displayed at St. James Church earlier this week at his funeral Mass, and think that such time spent is very important, too?

What do you think of the shorter February vacation?

Another suggestion was made on Feb. 4 that the number of days off be shortened to a three-day week, instead of two. Do you think that is enough time to get away for college visits or family trips?

Is it worth getting out of school a little earlier, and giving up some of those days off during the school year?

In the Somerset Hills school district, the last day of school this year is June 20, 2013. The district had been scheduled to have two days off for a long Presidents Day weekend, but those days were put back on the calendar to help make up for time lost to Superstorm Sandy last fall.

A parent at the Bernards Board of Education meeting on March 4 said that some in that school system say that going without a break for more than two months has been very hard. Still, the Somerset Hills district stuck to its schedule — and will let students out of school six days earlier in June than in Bernards Township schools.

Next February's vacation in Somerset Hills schools is the Friday and Monday, Feb. 14 and 17, surrounding Presidents Day. The last scheduled day of school is June 19, 2014.

And what about the Martin Luther King, Jr. holiday. It was pointed out that the January holiday is a national one, and parents may have the day off from work.

I admit we were taken a little aback when we moved from New York State, and found the holiday was not on the Bernards Township school calendar. But might students actually learn more about King if there are educational programs or in-service activities during a school day on the national holiday?

Do you think the activities planned during previous years when King's birthday commemoration was spent in school were adequate? Would you add anything?

Let us know what you think of the idea of having one week's vacation after New Year's, instead of two. Will it make your life easier, or make it harder?

About this column: Our Moms Talk column will discuss the latest hot-button parenting topics or issues that affect us all. Related Topics: School Calendar and moms talk

Kris Hintz

3:00 pm on Friday, March 15, 2013

As a college consultant, I would say that for sophomores and juniors in high school visiting colleges, it is not ideal to lose the MLK holiday and have shortened breaks over President's Day (or April, if that is also under consideration).

I advise students to visit campuses during these breaks, because there are students on campus, and they can get a realistic "feel" for how well they would fit in at a specific college (unlike the summer months, when many campuses become ghost towns). Seniors need short breaks in the winter and spring to visit campuses as admitted students, when they are making that final decision.

I also agree with others that quality time for families is compromised when these breaks are shortened or eliminated. I feel it is rather cynical to marginalize the value of these breaks by referring to them simply as "ski holidays." Many families choose to do educational local or out-of-state outings when they have the breathing time offered by these breaks--it all depends on the family. The value of formal education cannot be measured simply by the number of days spent in the classroom.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Linda Sadlouskos

4:05 pm on Friday, March 15, 2013

Interesting take, Kris -- I can't disagree with anything said. But (and although the 2013-14 schedule is set) how in future years would parents like to have students finish school a little earlier than the last week in June? Surely that also interferes with family activities and college/work plans for many older students.
I agree that some trips especially can be incredibly educational even if they are also fun!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ann Lauridsen

8:03 pm on Friday, March 15, 2013

School can finish earlier & keep BOTH Feb. and April breaks. 2013-2014 will not begin for a whole week AFTER Labor Day. This is why Feb. break was shortened. The calendar was changed in accordance withe the survey that was given. However the survey was not properly worded. It was leading and it didn't allow for the choice of keeping both Feb. and April. It was worded giving you the choice of one or the other. I spoke with one mom who had voted to reduce the Feb. vacation. Her family didn't travel because of the exreme expense that holiday week. She didn't even know that next year the vacation that she was voting to reduce was the week AFTER President's week. She stated that she would have not voted to reduce Feb. break had she known. The dates in Feb. were not made clear in the wording. The survey wasn't properly vetted! I don't know why school is starting the Monday after Labor Day. I understand that the teacher's contracts must be re-negotiated in order for teachers to begin before Labor Day as would be required with a Tuesday start date. (2 in service days are required prior to the kids arriving). I also understand that the Jewish Holiday falls on Thurs. That leaves a Friday start date. Why are we waiting until Monday to start school? Any family with a High Scool aged student involved in sports must be home around August 15. A large majority of the population can't even take advantage of this late school start by taking a less expense vacation or visit colleges Ann

Betsy Bacot-Aigner

5:58 pm on Friday, March 15, 2013

I am one of the many who are very upset about the shortening of the February break for 2013-2104. My main concern is for the students, particularly those in middle and high school, who will have to go from Jan. 2 until April 7 (over 3 months!!) with only 2 days off. Our school system is very challenging and provides an excellent education for our students, but I think it is imperative that the kids get "proper breaks" to relax and recharge, and certainly waiting over 3 months is going to negatively affect the students. Regardless of the multitude of ways that families utilize the week-long breaks -- looking at colleges, going away on "precious family vacations" (beach, skiing or other), educational local and out-of-state outings (as Kris Hintz mentioned above), or simply resting, relaxing, catching up on sleep or recovering from illnesses, to shorten the February break is to "take away" this crucial opportunity for all the students and families. I appreciate that the BOE faced particular challenges in revising next year's calendar, but I first of all think the "one break" should have been moved to March (to be fair) and it still makes no sense that we could not begin school on Friday 9/6. I certainly hope that, as Elaine Kusel stated at the meeting, next year should be a "test year" and not a "model". I believe it should be possible for future calendars to start earlier, end earlier and maintain a full February break.

Reply

Shirley Titus

2:01 pm on Sunday, March 17, 2013

Many students utilize these breaks for college visits and SAT / AP prep. Hence It is not surprising that 45 percent of the students voted to keep the February and April breaks. In light of this, the Board of education should consider starting school earlier, so students could still keep the breaks and end school early. Doing what is best for the students should be the top priority. Everything else should be secondary.

Reply

DELIAH

5:09 pm on Sunday, March 17, 2013

It's about time the calendar was revised! Having 2 week long breaks in addition to all of the other long weekends makes the end of the year very late in June. However, I do agree with others on this post who state that school for the 2013 year should start earlier that the second week of September. It is ridiculous! Why not go back to the model that students are excused without penaly for religious holidays and allow parents to take children out of school for those holidays as the parents see fit...not making certain religious holidays a mandatory day off? Let's get back to basics, a long weekend for thanksgiving, a week off for christmas, a week off around easter, a long weekend for memorial and getting out in early June?

Reply

Leave a comment