patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Mosque Applicant Urged to Double Parking Spaces

Four-hour hearing on application to build mosque in Liberty Corner begins with disagreement over necessary parking.

 
0 of 0
Architect Dan Lincoln, at microphone, and attorney Vincent Bisogno, on behalf of the Islamic Society of Basking Ridge, offer details and drawings while testiying before the Planning Board regarding a proposed new mosque at 124 Church Street in Basking Ridge. A court reporter took down official proceedings.
Photos (4)

Photos

A four-hour continued hearing on a proposal for a 4,252-square-foot mosque in Liberty Corner Village began Tuesday with the applicant's attorney saying he had learned the board's professionals now are asking that 110 parking spaces be provided for the house of worship if it is built, rather than the 50 spaces in the application.

The board's attorney, Jonathan Drill, said that he and David Banisch, planner for the township had concluded that number was appropriate as guided by 2010 International Traffic Engineers standards for mosques, as compared with churches and synagogues.

That brought a quick objection from Vincent Bisogno, attorney for the Islamic Society of Basking Ridge.

Bisogno said more than doubling the required parking spaces would ignore the township's own ordinances.

"Have you ever done this in the past where you raised the number of parking spaces?" asked Bisogno, a local attorney. He asked whether the churches or synagogues built in Basking Ridge had to follow the same rules.

Drill said that the society's own traffic engineer, Henry Ney, had mentioned the ITE when he was asked at a previous meeting if there is an objective standard for setting appropriate parking for mosques. He said the differentiated standards for parking for houses of worship were not released by the ITE until 2010.

Board Member Kevin Orr said he had been been asking "since day one" for the applicant to provide an objective standard for acceptable parking for a mosque. The hearings on the application began last August.

Orr said that the president of the Islamic Society, Ali Chaudry, had initially told the planners that it was his "best guess" that the mosque would serve about 150 members from the Somerset Hills and some surrounding communities.

Drill told Bisogno that it now is up to the applicant to show why fewer than the 110 parking spots are needed.

Bisogno said he was aware that the most attended religious service at the mosque would be from about noon to 2 p.m. on Fridays, and that worshippers might be arriving from work for attendance with only one or two per car. He said that maximum capacity for the mosque's prayer hall would be 142.

But Bisogno affirmed after the meeting that he does not agree with the 110-spot requirement. He also said that a change in parking requirements would affect other aspects of the plan for the mosque on a four-acre property at 124 Chuch Street.

Next meeting on mosque scheduled for Feb. 5

Before the meeting adjourned, Bisogno told the Planning Board that Ney would do additional research into parking patterns at other mosques and have a report by the next scheduled hearing on application at 7:30 p.m. on Feb. 5.

Also at that meeting, the architect for the project, Bernardsville-based Dan Lincoln, also president of The Historical Society of the Somerset Hills, also is scheduled to be back at that meeting to answer questions from the Planning Board about his testimony on Tuesday.

Lincoln already has described the mosque in public, but was called back on Tuesday to provide additional details.

Along with drawings of the proposed mosque — which he said was designed to make the building fit in with the neighborhood — Lincoln also answered questions about proposed capacity for the building. Lincoln said a planned multi-purpose room could hold up to 110 people, and he said it would not be used at the same time that services would be underway in a prayer hall.

Lincoln was asked to look into whether there is any way he can slightly lower the height of the roof. He said he does not think he could lower it significantly.

Lincoln also presented samples of some of the exterior materials that would be used for the building, which he said would be gray and covered with a clapboard-style siding.

Related Topics: Bernards Township Planning Board, Islamic Society of Basking Ridge, and Mosque

b flake

12:08 pm on Wednesday, January 9, 2013

If they are expecting 140 people to show up 110 parking spaces isn't an unreasonable request.

Reply

nancy campbell

8:24 pm on Thursday, January 10, 2013

I agree - Please , those who are apposing this mosque, think about the potential negative message you are sending to our community. This mosque is not much larger than some of the homes in Basking Ridge. The number of participants is low - the impact on the community is vurtually nothing. Stop making such a fuss -

Reply
Comment_arrow

LC

5:58 pm on Thursday, January 17, 2013

I think you should volunteer the lot next door to your home. If you think it's "nothing" to have a residential home turned into an institution with 110 parking spaces - great! - do it! Services five times a day, Sunday school, weddings, funerals, meetings, institutional lighting, run off, traffic, noise. What do you think about a fire truck trying to get out of the adjacent driveway when over a hundred cars are backed up at the nearby 4 way stop?

What's the "negative message" the opposed are sending? Go ahead and say it. Did you know that a Presbyterian Church, Grace Fellowship, and a Hindu temple were all turned away from Liberty Corner over 20 years ago because of neighborhood objection?

How can you project what the number of participants is? Have you ever seen a mosque during Jumma on a Friday.

I just hope they buy the property next door to you - then let's see what kind of tune you sing.

b flake

8:29 pm on Thursday, January 10, 2013

I wonder why the folks that want to build the Mosque would let parking spaces stand in the way, the incremental cost of building 110 vs 50 can't be that big a deal. Much better to have the parking than have overflow parking on the street and having the town force them to put in the parking after the fact.

Reply

HG

3:53 pm on Friday, January 11, 2013

Ms. Campbell,

I don't know how I fall on this one, but your argument that "[t]his mosque is not much larger than some of the homes in Basking Ridge" strikes me as supporting the argument of the opposition. 150 people don't regularly visit homes in Basking Ridge. Your logic seems to support the idea that the building, and potentially the land, are too small to support such a large undertaking.

Reply

b flake

7:38 pm on Sunday, January 13, 2013

This will never be built, the parking issue makes it a non issue. If you need 110 spots, I am sure the coverage "issue" will make this whole thing blow up. There is no seemingly need for a Mosque in BR.

Reply

Jack Arnold

2:44 pm on Wednesday, January 16, 2013

Another lawsuit waiting to happen. Just because it is a "permitted use" doesn't mean the Planning Board doesn't get to attach reasonable conditions to their approval. Parking is one of these and they are applying a recognized engineering standard. However, just wait for the applicant to cry "discrimination" and go to court.

Reply
Comment_arrow

LC

5:51 pm on Thursday, January 17, 2013

They have already begun implying discrimination.

Rashid

11:51 am on Friday, February 22, 2013

the seeds planted by Newt Gingrich's sugar daddy, Sheldon Adelson are bearing fruit!

Reply

Rashid

11:52 am on Friday, February 22, 2013

Sheldon Adelson money is aiming to promote a Kristallnacht in North America.

Reply

Leave a comment