UPDATE: As Problems Persist, Bus Routes to be Changed Again
Superintendent of county Education Services Commission expects routes to be fixed in two weeks.
An update of the township's school bus routes, implemented this fall with the aid of a computer software program, was supposed to make bus service more efficient for those students eligible for busing.
The revised routes also were supposed to recognize changes in where populations of students live, and road changes, the Board of Education was told on Monday night by Hal Dunsavage, superintendent of the Somerset County Education Services Commission.
Instead, according to parents and board members who also are parents, schedules and routes had been thrown into disarray. The school's bus service is contracted through the Somerset County ESC.
ADDED: "Transportation at SCESC [Somerset County Education Services Provider, which provides bus service] is working with the software company to provide the quickest solution possible," School Business Administrator Nick Markarian said in an email on Wednesday.
As of Monday, some buses for middle school students were arriving 20 minutes earlier than usual, meaning most students miss that bus, while buses for Ridge High School—which normally arrive after the middle school bus—are showing up after 7 a.m.
At the meeting, board President Susan Carlsson said that high school in The Hills section of the township particularly have been seeing buses arrive at times past 7 a.m. "For the past three days"—since school started last Thursday—"they are getting to school late."
Board member Priti Shah said she had been told of bus stops that totally were missed by drivers, requiring parents to transport the entire bus stop of students. "What's being done about that?" she asked.
A persistent problem, she said, is, "Consistently, at the beginning of the year, drivers...didn't know the routes."
Other parents told of hearing stories of a kindergarten student being dropped off at the wrong location. There also were reports of clusters of four or five buses, particularly in The Hills, all passing by one corner and then backing up behind each other on the way to school.
Dunsavage said the updating had been performed with the aid of an outsourced company, which he said he will hold accountable for the problems. He said that within the next two weeks, most of the routes will be put back to pretty much what they were in the previous year, except in certain cases.
When the new routes are set, Dunsavage said new bus passes will be given to the school. School officials, including Superintendent Valerie Goger, said that the new passes will be issued at school, but she doesn't know yet exactly how they will be distributed.
He said the priority changes, to be made as soon as possible, are those that supposedly had young children crossing streets to reach buses, or routes and stops with other safety concerns. He said other routes will be examined for efficiency, after hearing parents complain that some buses left The Hills and heading up nearly to Bernardsville before heading to their school destination.
Dunsavage asked parents and board members to email the ESC with specific information, including the child's name, address, bus stop and the situation. He said parents would receive an answer back if they email BaskingRidge@sc.esc.k12.nj.us.
He said first-day-of-school bus problems were worsened by heavy rains, and flooding that made it impossible for some bus drivers even to get to work.
He also told the board that in future years, he will make sure that bus drivers go on a practice run before the first day of school. "This is not going to happen again next year. I can tell you that," Dunsavage told the school board and public.
One mother complained that a year ago September her child had been picked up and then she encountered the bus driver in Bernardsville. She said she had to lead him back to the Oak Street School.
"Why not spend $100 and give them a GPS?" she asked.
Linda Sadlouskos
8:08 am on Tuesday, September 13, 2011
Have you been having problems with school bus routes/stops? Or has the bus been showing up as usual for you? How about this (Tuesday) morning?
Amy Garrett
12:05 pm on Tuesday, September 13, 2011
We did have trouble again today! I thought by day 4 things would subside. My son's bus came 11 minutes early today. I had to drive him and some others who missed it - very frustrating.
Fred Douglis
8:46 am on Tuesday, September 13, 2011
Every bus should have a GPS both for guiding the driver and for enabling the bus company and parents to track the buses in real time. What year is this?
Linda Sadlouskos
10:11 am on Tuesday, September 13, 2011
Edna, Thanks for insight. I know my son said he had the same driver as the previous year, so that driver must have known the route quite well. Undoubtedly, too, as Mr. Dunsavage did mention at the meeting, the heavy rains and flooding that affected both buses and the ability of drivers even to get to work affected the first day's bus service.
Alicia R. Camlibel, Ph.D., LPC
10:40 am on Tuesday, September 13, 2011
There is NO excuse for leaving a kindergarten student at the wrong stop. There is also no excuse for bus drivers not to know their routes, check the names of each child as they get on the bus, and before getting off the bus at the end of the day making sure the child is at the correct stop and there is a parent/guardian there to meet the child, especially when they are young. Safety and accountability need to be the number one priority.
Rich Lawrence
11:32 am on Tuesday, September 13, 2011
I am a bus driver and this is my 5th year of driving William Annin students and my first year with a Liberty Corner run. Every Bernards bus route was given a practice run by the bus driver before the start of school contrary to what Mr. Dunsavge hinted at in the above article. The real problem was the morning of the 1st day of school, nearly every bus driver found new route sheets with changes in them in their mailbox. Plus there was no one from transportation management to answer any questions about the new route sheets. So I strongly disagree that the problems were the bus drivers fault and a closer look should be made at the transportation management.
n
4:27 pm on Tuesday, September 13, 2011
Thank you Rich, It is a hard, thankless and important job you do w/little pay. Maybe some of the parents that think it is a breeze, should do your job for a week. I'm sure after the first route, they will change their tune.
TJ
12:24 pm on Wednesday, September 14, 2011
Rich -- I assure you that most parents I know don't fault the drivers but see the company and management of the bus company to be the issues. If a driver doesn't know his/her route that means that they haven't been given the proper time, information, and/or tools to learn the route.
Linda Sadlouskos
2:23 pm on Thursday, September 15, 2011
School officials said the issue was still being worked on as of the end of this week. How is your child's bus service doing?