patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

The Cost of Voting Down the School Budget

Adults of Basking Ridge have betrayed their responsibility towards students by defeating the school budget.

 

I cannot tell a lie: I didn't vote for the budget in the school election last Tuesday. In fact, like 88 percent of Bernards Township residents and 70 percent of registered voters, I didn't vote at all. Although I turned 18 a few months ago, I must admit that I did not register to vote until a week before the election, which put me past the deadline for participation.

As a senior at Ridge High School, I shook my head in disbelief as I looked at the election results posted on the Bernards Board of Education homepage. I was shocked by the fact that our township's voters defeated a budget essential to the maintenance of educational excellence, as well as by the low voter turnout in this school election.

Scrolling down the district homepage, I noted ironically the next announcement: the enthusiastic declaration that Forbes has "named our district of its 25 Best Schools for Your Housing Buck!!" I cannot help but wonder whether our school district will retain that ranking five years from now, when the effects of fewer teachers, fewer courses, and fewer enrichment opportunities have taken their toll on Bernards Township education.

After all, other school districts have eight period days and half-day kindergarten—but they are not ranked in the top 25 in the nation. Families do not move into just any town for the school district, but Bernards Township has always been dedicated to its children and their education.

Of course, I recognize that many Bernards Township residents do not have children in the school system and thus gain little direct benefit from higher taxes. Certainly, even with lower state funding, some Basking Ridge families will be able to supplement their children's education with extracurricular sports, music lessons, or tutoring. But for most families, these activities cost more per week than a 5 percent tax increase would add in a year.

Losing class periods and academic opportunities not only poses a financial strain on their parents, but hurts students' high school experiences and chances of going to good colleges. In my opinion, public education should be the responsibility of all Americans: the state of our country in 20 years depends on the education my generation receives today.

So, although the budget lost by 416 votes, I cannot help but feel guilty about my lack of political involvement.  I tell myself that I should have registered to vote earlier, that I should have urged 415 of my closest friends to do the same. I should have written more emotional columns for the Patch, or done something, anything, to help the budget pass. In fact, a junior at Ridge told me, "We, the student body, don't have the right to complain since the vast majority of us did not campaign, knock on doors, or even get many of the seniors to vote… we didn't do our part to convey how vital the tax raise is."

But is it really the part of students to ensure that the Board of Education budget passes? The Board members who wrote the budget were elected long before I turned 18. My parents, who decided to move to Basking Ridge predominantly because of its excellent school system, did not ask me if I wanted to live in a town with a well-regarded high school. As a high school student, I am not supposed to want more schoolwork. Instead, my job is to absorb information in class, gain experiences out of class, and enjoy my time in high school so that I can decide I want to do for the rest of my life.

Meanwhile, I believe that it is the responsibility of my parents and the parents of my classmates to ensure that Bernards Township students get the best possible education that we possibly can. And while we students should definitely vote and make our views known, the failure of our budget to pass ultimately reflects the failure of our town to ensure an excellent education for its children. The adults of Bernards Township should act in the best interest of the students—because ultimately, our generation will be responsible for the welfare of all Americans.

Bev Darvin Cwerner

9:30 am on Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Thank you for for this very thoughtful article. It is very disappointing that our budget failed. We will do our best to maintain the integrity of our program, depite the reduced funds.

This defeat serves as a reminder of the importance of every vote. College bound students should remember to request absentee ballots, Ridge students of voting age should cast their vote, and those not of voting age should remind their family, friends, and neighbors of the importance of voting.

Reply

Tim

5:03 pm on Wednesday, April 28, 2010

With the economy in such tough shape these last few years your teachers have enjoyed raises each of the last three years along with free healthcare and pension programs that they do not contribute a dime for. Its time to get spending under control.

Perhaps you will understand someday when you actually have to pay taxes.

Reply

Alex

10:23 pm on Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Instead of apologizing and giving excuses for not doing enough to pass the budget, you should be writing about what students can do now to help, what parents can do to make sure their children still get a high quality education, and what our community needs to do to ensure the reasons why people voted 'no' do not reappear next year.

Reply

BR Mom

8:21 am on Thursday, April 29, 2010

The BOE did not push hard enough when they agreed to a 1.5% pay raise for teachers, so that the 1.5% cost of benefits kept their salaries "flat" for next year. There are people out of work in this town. There are people with pay cuts and no bonuses in this town. It is not unreasonable to expect our teachers to pay into their benefits and feel it. I am shocked that the budget did not pass, and yet the most "experienced" BOE members were re-elected!

Also, it is ridiculous to say that moving to an 8 period day, if necessary, will hurt our kids' chances of getting into college. The rigor of the high school curriculum is not in question, but essentially the number of study halls and electives that children take would be decreased. Also, each year, the high school guidance department prepares a profile of the school to accompany each transcript sent out to college; this profile explains what classes/options are available at the school. Many, many excellent public schools will face the same decision/cuts when our children apply to college, and the colleges will know this. They do not hold this against the kids!

Reply

mary

12:41 pm on Thursday, April 29, 2010

The budget was voted down because people CANNOT afford to live in NJ. If no one lives here we won't need any schools at all. Wake up people! We cannot afford 600 plus school districts. WE NEED TO CONSOLIDATE DISTRICTS AND ELIMINATE administration. In Bedminster (and in many other areas) there is only one school! Why do we need a separate district for that!

Reply

Lisa Winter

9:51 am on Saturday, May 1, 2010

New Jersey has among the best schools in the nation. Our excellent schools are an important reason for families wanting to move INTO the state, and for businesses to settle here too. In Basking Ridge, our excellent school system raises our home values - our schools are the number one reason so many families are eager to move here.

Our school district already lost over $5 million in state aid for this year and next year. Additional severe cuts to the budget will seriously jeopardize school quality. Our whole community will suffer as a result for years to come. And it's a shame, because the Bernards Twp school district is already one of the lowest cost districts in the state. It's terribly unfair that state aid to schools was cut and the burden thrown back to local property tax payers.

In my opinion, our state's problem with taxes is not that we are taxed too high - it's that NJ relies too much on property taxes, which are very difficult for seniors and middle to lower income people. Other states use the income tax, a much more fair tax, and provide more state aid to schools. A good article on NJ's tax situation is here: http://baskingridge.patch.com/articles/new-jersey-taxed-to-death-or-not-taxed-enough-7

A good website about NJ's combined taxes is here: http://www.itepnet.org/wp2009/nj_whopays_factsheet.pdf If you look at all of NJ's taxes combined - property tax, sales tax and income tax - we compare well to other states.

Reply

Leave a comment